Bad service doesn't really cut it. A terrible experience better describes the events leading from my purchasing a voucher to Exotic Sportscar Hire (a subsidiary of Stemidoju Pty Ltd, a company based in North Sydney) through Travelzoo Local (Australia) Pty Ltd late last year for $189. This should have been a fun thing. Maybe I'm at fault for being overly trusting, but this is the first time I've had trouble with a product sold through Travelzoo, or any of the scoupon issuing companies.
I bought the voucher for an 8-hour hire of either a Porsche Boxter or a Mercedes SLK convertible as a Christmas present. My good wife has had a lifelong ambition to possess a Mercedes Sports. Warning bells should have registered with Exotic Sportscar Hire (ESCH)'s demand for massive amounts of personal information, and lack of responsiveness to our request for a later starting time and preference for the Mercedes.
After making the 8am Sunday meeting time in a Glenelg hotel car park, Elizabeth had a brilliant day driving the issued Porsche Boxter, after first cleaning it up a bit. She also had to point out to the ESCH representative that he was 7 kilometres out in his speedometer reading.
Despite Travelzoo's fine print stating that there would be a "credit card pre-authorisation required with a limit of $3,000", the ESCH representative actually deducted $3,000 out of her account. Alarm bells really started ringing when ECSH informed us by email two days later that the $3,000 security deposit would not be repaid for 28 working/business days. Even after that time passed, it took a week of constant emails via the ESCH website to receive a refund of $701 and a non-readable reconciliation statement. When we managed to get a PDF reconciliation statement we were staggered at charges totalling $299 (i.e. in addition to the $189 already paid to Travelzoo for the voucher). The statement included all sorts of extra charges: an extra driver charge (when there was only one); a cleaning charge (the car was returned in the same state as collection); a 4% ($120) credit card charge on the security deposit (not mentioned at the time), and GST charges (not previously mentioned). We have calculated the only amount owing is $38.80, after deducting the $20 cheese platter voucher we never received.
I've not yet fully tested what Travelzoo might do to help. They are still promoting deals with Exotic Sportscar Hire. I did get a response originally when I had not been getting any from ESCH. The Travelzoo officer said that she hadn't been aware that ESCH kept the security deposit so long.
After more hassle, ESCH refunded a further $2,000 on 19/03/2013.
I feel the value of Travelzoo promotions generally are becoming just that, and not the great value they used to be. Whether we get the remaining $299 of the security deposit back only time will tell but it has been a lot of stress and wasted time. Stress is not good.
Another experience that generated those tight chest feelings was my visit to the Ashford Day Hospital on Monday (4/03/2013). I moved between four waiting rooms over the more than three and a half hours waiting for my operation. Maybe I'm being overly sensitive but I found the whole process impersonal. Even the anaesthetist had difficulty finding a spare room when he needed to interview me. I had expected more because of really positive experiences with the Adelaide Cancer Centre (ACC), which I think also comes under the Ashford. I was referred to have a port inserted in my chest for the easier delivery of the chemotherapy I'm getting at the Centre. Technically the service from the surgeon, anaesthetist and Ashford theatre staff in doing this was first rate.
I stayed in the Ashford overnight for observation, which just continued an already bad day. No offer was made to sponge me down from the operation or help me change out of the surgical gowns into pyjamas. The ties on the gowns kept unravelling every time I went to the toilet (a not infrequent event) and I started worrying I might dislodge the chords dangling from the needle in my chest. I guess there could have been good reasons for just offering me a sandwich and cheese and crackers that night. Not having eaten since early morning I was pretty hungry and hoping for a proper meal, perhaps supported with a glass of wine. No main course was offered for breakfast either, just cereal and a piece of toast.
The next day I was up, had a shower, dressed in my usual clothes and out of there for a proper meal - a wonderful feeling.
While I am laying out those experiences that have given me grief, I have to mention my attempt last year to have the refrigerator repaired. The fridge was making these intermittent loud noises, which from my internet search seemed to be a slipping fan belt in the motor and beyond my capability. I phoned what I thought was a local company, but I was directed to a call centre for Electrical Refrigeration Services or ERS, and and according to their account this is somehow connected with Sharpe Electrical. The technician had an offsider whose job appeared to be to prepare the bill.
Of course the noise had stopped when he got there and he simply stated "I don't know what it is". I tried to explain further what I had heard, but he just said that one of the motors probably needed replacing and that he couldn't tell which one it was without hearing the noise, and that I needed to pay him $110. Before I knew it I was handing over the credit card and they were out the door. The whole thing was over in less than five minutes. I wouldn't have felt so bad if he had at least taken the back off the machine and pretended to check the mechanism for awhile. I'm now putting up with the noise. I think when I get the money I'll just buy a new refrigerator.
And what is happening at Waterfall Gully? One of my ways at keeping healthy is to do the inspiring, but exhausting, trek from there up to Mount Lofty and back down again. The trail goes through a range of bushland, provides spectacular views and frequent contact with native beasties. Many of the people I meet along the trail are overseas visitors, no doubt directed there by Tourism SA. This is a very popular walk or, in the case of the very fit, run. Waterfall Gully is also now being used for weddings, in addition to the restaurant that has been built into the side of the hill. All of this is administered by Parks SA. But why is there so little parking provided? Even during the week parking overflows to the road, but on the weekend it is crazy trying to find a park and the man giving out $140 tickets for illegal parkers is kept fully occupied. Car drivers are aggressive, as only Australians can be when fighting over scarce resources. What must our international visitors be thinking?
I have a negative impression of Parks SA. The only officers I can remember seeing are those at places like the gates at the Innes national Park where they take your money. When I first came to South Australia, I brought with me many positive experiences of camping and bush walking in Queensland. But the camping grounds I've been to here have been expensive and unpatrolled. The main animals are vermin, rabbits and foxes. I gave up camping at the designated grounds because they were invariably invaded by drunken all night parties. These were no small affairs but often supported by large loud speakers, spotlights and beer kegs. People who attempted to reason with the party goers were just abused or ignored.
I do not mean to give the impression that much of the service industry here in South Australia is bad, although some of it is down there with the worst I've seen overseas. I have also had many good experiences. For example, I must have the fortune to be a member of one of the best gyms in the world - Health Works, at Marden. There is the usual top of the range of equipment and classes, but the owner/managers, Wayne and Des, maintain a fun, but professional, atmosphere, a good distraction from the pain of exercise. With the help of new technology, they've now open twenty-four hours, but I prefer to go when the guys are there.
Since I last reported I've had a few small writing successes. In the middle of last year I won a Campbelltown Literary Encouragement Award and some money courtesy of the Campbelltown City Council. I titled my short story, The man with the frog growing under his arm, a whimsical, horror tale about the history of Thornden Park. For anyone tempted to read a fairly short story this can be found at the following link: The man with the frog growing under his arm. I was criticised for my paragraph formatting (spacing between paragraphs rather than indenting the first line). I'm not sure...
I was really pleased to have the story of my great uncle, and his family, published as "Armidale's Cordial King: William Henry Logan", Armidale and District Historical Society, Jounal and Proceedings, No. 55, September 2012, pp 63 - 79.
I bought the voucher for an 8-hour hire of either a Porsche Boxter or a Mercedes SLK convertible as a Christmas present. My good wife has had a lifelong ambition to possess a Mercedes Sports. Warning bells should have registered with Exotic Sportscar Hire (ESCH)'s demand for massive amounts of personal information, and lack of responsiveness to our request for a later starting time and preference for the Mercedes.
After making the 8am Sunday meeting time in a Glenelg hotel car park, Elizabeth had a brilliant day driving the issued Porsche Boxter, after first cleaning it up a bit. She also had to point out to the ESCH representative that he was 7 kilometres out in his speedometer reading.
Despite Travelzoo's fine print stating that there would be a "credit card pre-authorisation required with a limit of $3,000", the ESCH representative actually deducted $3,000 out of her account. Alarm bells really started ringing when ECSH informed us by email two days later that the $3,000 security deposit would not be repaid for 28 working/business days. Even after that time passed, it took a week of constant emails via the ESCH website to receive a refund of $701 and a non-readable reconciliation statement. When we managed to get a PDF reconciliation statement we were staggered at charges totalling $299 (i.e. in addition to the $189 already paid to Travelzoo for the voucher). The statement included all sorts of extra charges: an extra driver charge (when there was only one); a cleaning charge (the car was returned in the same state as collection); a 4% ($120) credit card charge on the security deposit (not mentioned at the time), and GST charges (not previously mentioned). We have calculated the only amount owing is $38.80, after deducting the $20 cheese platter voucher we never received.
I've not yet fully tested what Travelzoo might do to help. They are still promoting deals with Exotic Sportscar Hire. I did get a response originally when I had not been getting any from ESCH. The Travelzoo officer said that she hadn't been aware that ESCH kept the security deposit so long.
After more hassle, ESCH refunded a further $2,000 on 19/03/2013.
I feel the value of Travelzoo promotions generally are becoming just that, and not the great value they used to be. Whether we get the remaining $299 of the security deposit back only time will tell but it has been a lot of stress and wasted time. Stress is not good.
Another experience that generated those tight chest feelings was my visit to the Ashford Day Hospital on Monday (4/03/2013). I moved between four waiting rooms over the more than three and a half hours waiting for my operation. Maybe I'm being overly sensitive but I found the whole process impersonal. Even the anaesthetist had difficulty finding a spare room when he needed to interview me. I had expected more because of really positive experiences with the Adelaide Cancer Centre (ACC), which I think also comes under the Ashford. I was referred to have a port inserted in my chest for the easier delivery of the chemotherapy I'm getting at the Centre. Technically the service from the surgeon, anaesthetist and Ashford theatre staff in doing this was first rate.
I stayed in the Ashford overnight for observation, which just continued an already bad day. No offer was made to sponge me down from the operation or help me change out of the surgical gowns into pyjamas. The ties on the gowns kept unravelling every time I went to the toilet (a not infrequent event) and I started worrying I might dislodge the chords dangling from the needle in my chest. I guess there could have been good reasons for just offering me a sandwich and cheese and crackers that night. Not having eaten since early morning I was pretty hungry and hoping for a proper meal, perhaps supported with a glass of wine. No main course was offered for breakfast either, just cereal and a piece of toast.
The next day I was up, had a shower, dressed in my usual clothes and out of there for a proper meal - a wonderful feeling.
While I am laying out those experiences that have given me grief, I have to mention my attempt last year to have the refrigerator repaired. The fridge was making these intermittent loud noises, which from my internet search seemed to be a slipping fan belt in the motor and beyond my capability. I phoned what I thought was a local company, but I was directed to a call centre for Electrical Refrigeration Services or ERS, and and according to their account this is somehow connected with Sharpe Electrical. The technician had an offsider whose job appeared to be to prepare the bill.
Of course the noise had stopped when he got there and he simply stated "I don't know what it is". I tried to explain further what I had heard, but he just said that one of the motors probably needed replacing and that he couldn't tell which one it was without hearing the noise, and that I needed to pay him $110. Before I knew it I was handing over the credit card and they were out the door. The whole thing was over in less than five minutes. I wouldn't have felt so bad if he had at least taken the back off the machine and pretended to check the mechanism for awhile. I'm now putting up with the noise. I think when I get the money I'll just buy a new refrigerator.
And what is happening at Waterfall Gully? One of my ways at keeping healthy is to do the inspiring, but exhausting, trek from there up to Mount Lofty and back down again. The trail goes through a range of bushland, provides spectacular views and frequent contact with native beasties. Many of the people I meet along the trail are overseas visitors, no doubt directed there by Tourism SA. This is a very popular walk or, in the case of the very fit, run. Waterfall Gully is also now being used for weddings, in addition to the restaurant that has been built into the side of the hill. All of this is administered by Parks SA. But why is there so little parking provided? Even during the week parking overflows to the road, but on the weekend it is crazy trying to find a park and the man giving out $140 tickets for illegal parkers is kept fully occupied. Car drivers are aggressive, as only Australians can be when fighting over scarce resources. What must our international visitors be thinking?
I have a negative impression of Parks SA. The only officers I can remember seeing are those at places like the gates at the Innes national Park where they take your money. When I first came to South Australia, I brought with me many positive experiences of camping and bush walking in Queensland. But the camping grounds I've been to here have been expensive and unpatrolled. The main animals are vermin, rabbits and foxes. I gave up camping at the designated grounds because they were invariably invaded by drunken all night parties. These were no small affairs but often supported by large loud speakers, spotlights and beer kegs. People who attempted to reason with the party goers were just abused or ignored.
I do not mean to give the impression that much of the service industry here in South Australia is bad, although some of it is down there with the worst I've seen overseas. I have also had many good experiences. For example, I must have the fortune to be a member of one of the best gyms in the world - Health Works, at Marden. There is the usual top of the range of equipment and classes, but the owner/managers, Wayne and Des, maintain a fun, but professional, atmosphere, a good distraction from the pain of exercise. With the help of new technology, they've now open twenty-four hours, but I prefer to go when the guys are there.
Since I last reported I've had a few small writing successes. In the middle of last year I won a Campbelltown Literary Encouragement Award and some money courtesy of the Campbelltown City Council. I titled my short story, The man with the frog growing under his arm, a whimsical, horror tale about the history of Thornden Park. For anyone tempted to read a fairly short story this can be found at the following link: The man with the frog growing under his arm. I was criticised for my paragraph formatting (spacing between paragraphs rather than indenting the first line). I'm not sure...
I was really pleased to have the story of my great uncle, and his family, published as "Armidale's Cordial King: William Henry Logan", Armidale and District Historical Society, Jounal and Proceedings, No. 55, September 2012, pp 63 - 79.
Hi William
ReplyDeleteI would like to speak to you further regarding your experience about ESCH as I have friend in a similar situation and they are about to take legal action. Are you happy for an offline discussion?
SC
Hi SC
DeleteI'm happy to help if I can. My email is wbloganau@yahoo.com.au.
Cheers
William
Hi William and SC:
DeleteMore victims like us
http://www.lacartes.com/business/EXOTIC-SPORTS-CAR-HIRE-/26327
SC- I have recently had an appauling experience with ESCH and would like to help your friend too. These people need to be investigated.
DeleteMy email is: fringes@bigpond.com
I had a conciliation meeting yesterday with that 'man' at ESCH at the SA Office of Consumer and Business Affairs. We ended up settling as my husband and I did not want to go through the court process. I am happy to help anyone that does though. I can be contacted at fringes@bigpond.com
ReplyDelete